Showing posts with label Building-type. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Building-type. Show all posts

Monday, March 13, 2017

The Checkerboard Plan: High-Density Medium-Rise Honeycomb Apartments


The medium-rise Honeycomb apartment with the checkerboard-plan can provide an answer to the problem of affordable housing in the main urban centres of Malaysia. Let me first introduce the concept.

The basic checkerboard layout plan consists of eight duplex units arranged along a 3-storey high sky-court.


Figure 1 A sky-court neighbourhood of 8 units

On each floor are four of these sky-courts that are linked by a lift lobby.


Figure 2 Four sky-courts on one  floor in one block

This is the view of the 3-storey sky-court. In this “Honeycomb Apartment” concept, every resident can step out of her main door to her front yard and beyond that, a landscaped courtyard – or “sky-court” with a garden fence off the edge. 

Figure 3 View of 3-storey Courtyard


The doors lining the courtyard on the right are the front doors to the apartments. All apartments in this “neighbourhood in the sky” will have such doors, leading into a lofty three storey high sky-court which contains private and shared gardens.
This is a look at the floor plans of a pair of apartments. As per the Honeycomb apartment arrangement, units on the courtyard garden level either have stairs going down to bedrooms on the floor below, or have stairs going up to bedrooms on the floor above. The typical apartment is a duplex unit with living room, dining and kitchen on the courtyard level and three bedrooms, two bathrooms, a utility space and a dry yard on the upper level or the level below.

Figure 4 One level above, Courtyard level, and one level below

Residents here enjoy the benefits of a Honeycomb neighbourhood. They share a communal courtyard with small number of other households, making it easy for neighbours to get to know and interact each other. There is sufficient space and light to garden just outside their home.
With many “eyes” overlooking the sky-court along with safety measures such as a garden fence at the edge of the sky-court and child barriers at strategic locations, the sky-court can be made safe for children. Children can play just outside in the courtyard, making this apartment more suitable for families.

The typical floor plans of medium-rise Honeycomb apartments are shown below:

Figure 5 Podium Level and Podium Level + 1

Figure 6 Floor below Cortyard level, Courtyard Level, and floor above Courtyard Level

Figure 7  The Honeycomb 3-storey Courtyard Arrangement


Figure 8 Another view of the Couutyard

Eight apartments front the typical courtyard, about 8 x 16 metres on plan and 9 metres high. They each have a front-yard 4m wide and 2.4m deep where residents can tend their own garden. It also provides a buffer between bypassing residents and the front door, providing a measure of privacy to the living room and still allowing people inside a view of the sky-court.
By securing the edge with an anti-climb fence and securing access to the lift lobby and escape staircases, the courtyard is suitable for smaller children to play with their parents and neighbours looking on.


Figure 9 Entrance View

At the ground level, the entrance is connected to the public street by stairs that go up a sloped garden that screens the car park behind it. Off the entrance are two courtyards opposite each other which have shops; they each lead to the two wings of the apartment block. In the middle is a community centre with Surau, multi-purpose hall and kindergarten.


Figure 10 View of Entrance Court

The high density of 130 units per acre is achieved by the 12-storey version of the checkerboard plan which has a basement car park where the parking standard is 2.2 car parks per apartment, or with just the ground floor car park where the requirement is 1.1 car park per apartment.

Figure 11 View of 12 Storey Version


Figure 12 Another View of 12-storey version

Unlike conventional high-rise apartments which have similar densities, here the housing blocks are not divorced from the street level, separated by multiple levels of car parks. The ground floor car park can be easily screened-off from the front by a garden that slopes up to the first floor and from the sides and rear by walls and rows of trees.

The bulky mass of blocks is also easily broken up by the sky-courts and façade treatment which introduce strong vertical elements that counter the horizontality of the floors. Adopting duplex floor plans also avoids the monotonous repetition of window patterns on the elevation. 
The checkerboard-plan is just another variation of X-plan Honeycomb apartment layout that was introduced in Chapter 11. In this version, the sky-courts are three storeys rather than six. The cost saving features of the X-plan have been retained:

  • Corridors have been eliminated and substituted instead by sky-courts.
  • The lifts stop only on every three floors: compared to having to stop at every floor, fewer lifts can be installed without increasing waiting time
However, to solve the real-world problem of providing housing in Malaysia’s major urban centres, more cuts need to be made.

How the checkerboard-plan can make high densities acceptable, maximize site coverage to fit in more units on medium-rise buildings and provide sufficient car parks efficiently will be discussed in the next post.


Back to Table of Contents

Friday, December 2, 2016

Point-Block Low-Rise Low-Cost Apartments

Apart from the shop-house, the other building-type that I had developed as a solution to low-cost housing was the 5-storey walk-up flat.

Most walk-up apartments in Malaysia can be described as slab blocks. In a paper written in 2000 I argued that the point block low rise apartment is not only more aesthetically pleasing and socially functional, it is also an economically viable alternative. 

In the previous six years, I had attempted to design low cost and low-medium cost housing that met the strict cost limits required by developers, the rules set by government authorities, and the same time achieve the aesthetic and social aims of my practice.

My firm approached this problem by designing and refining generic designs capable of being applied across the various sites, requirements and parameters of different projects. We promoted the point-block low-rise apartment as a generic design which is superior to the ubiquitous slab block low rise apartment. 

THE ECONOMIC ADVANTAGES OF POINT BLOCK LOW RISE APARTMENT COMPARED TO THE SLAB BLOCK LOW RISE APARTMENT 

The slab block low-rise walk-up apartment is the standard solution in big towns and cities in Malaysia. The typical design comprises four or five storeys of apartments strung out in two lines opposite each other with access corridors and voids in the middle, and staircases at both ends of the corridor


There are of course many variations to this basic concept. We just must adapt specific dimensions and layout to customize the design. The slab block, in my opinion is not very pleasing aesthetically, and in social terms, now too positive either. Its main advantage is that it is cheap. Certainly, it is cheap compared to terrace houses or bungalows because it use less land. Typically, 50 to 60 units per acre compared to 20 units / acre for terrace house and even less tor bungalows. The construction cost for unit is also low compared to the bungalow or terrace house because there are lots of shared walls, shared structure, floors and roofing.



 Against to the point-block, the slab block certainly looks cheaper. And therefore, it is cheaper goes the implicit common-sense logic. I challenged that common-sense conclusion.



The point block walk-up apartment comprises a single staircase in the core and four or more units around that central staircase. Every unit is a corner unit. The point blocks that we’ve designed certainly do not look cheap but there are specific and verifiable reasons why point blocks are cost-effective:



DENSITY (UNITS/ACRE)


Land is an important cost factor in housing. Commonly it is 10% - 20% of the total development cost of a mixed housing project. The accepted density for low-cost low rise apartments (in most States in Malaysia) is 60 units per acre. It is not easy to achieve this density in an aesthetically pleasing and socially acceptable manner. You can maximise units for any given plot of land by using bigger blocks. Right? Well, not always true.

It you have two similar round vessels of say 1 cubic meter capacity each and fill one vessel with large stones and the other vessel with small pebbles which vessel would contain more material? The vessel with the small pebbles will have more material. There would be less spaces between the pebbles compared with the bigger stones. In a similar manner, small blocks can fill up a site better than standard slab blocks. This tends to be true for big sites, especially sites with irregular shape. In the case of small sites, blocks designed to the shape of the land do better.

SPACE EFFICIENCY (NET SELLABLE AREA / GROSS AREA)

Small point blocks are more efficient compared to slab blocks. In particular, the corridor is eliminated and the staircase and landing area is minimal. It is usual for point blocks to have 60% or less of corridor and staircase space per unit. It is not in typical for slab block with double loading corridors'# to have 76sf (7sm) external circulation space per unit. Slab block with single loading corridors can have external circulation space 96sf (9sm) or more per unit. Architects sometimes think that the more units share staircases, the more cost effective the design, but the corridors that lead to the staircases also add cost.

INTERNAL LAYOUT EFFICIENCY

This is about maximising space usage in units. In the point-block generic design, every unit is a corner unit. There is a cost penalty tor this - there is less shared walls between units and there is less shared beams and columns. However, there is a benefit - less shared walls means more external walls, and with more external walls for light and ventilation it is easier to design efficient and functional rooms. In our point block designs, we try to maximise usable space and minimise circulation space. In intermediate units of slab blocks, external wall is at a premium. Voids have to be cut out in the interior of the block to provide windows to receive what little light and ventilation these air wells can provide. Or else, the exterior elevations require deep recesses to bring in light and ventilation to the middle areas.

The depth of the units, often long in relation to the width, results in long circulation spaces required to access the outer rooms. This layout also involves other substantial compromises in functional design. Firstly, entrances are invariably at the dining area near the kitchen. This is not functional but seems to be the accepted standard even for medium to high cost apartments. Secondly, there will be some bedrooms, the kitchen, drying yard and some toilets which will have to make do with light and ventilation from air wells. Thirdly, entering the apartment from where the kitchen and drying yard is situated creates the impression of entering a home from its backyard. Fourthly, bedrooms are difficult to cluster together in a private zone separate from the semi-private living and dining areas.


Blocks with small footprints require small earth platforms. Blocks with big footprints require larger earth, platforms. A series of small earth platforms generally involve less volume then a series of larger platforms cut out from the same original slope profile. From the same illustration, it is also intuitively clear that easier to arrange point blocks to sit on cut ground than it is to arrange slab blocks to meet this same requirement. Having original ground to sit on rather than fill ground can save a lot in foundation costs. Of course, slab blocks can be arranged along contours to minimise earthworks, though this limits the flexibility of the layout and is not effective where the land slope in two directions. Another possibility is to stagger the slab block down the slope, this requires retaining walls or stilts which again adds cost, and reduces standardisation.

Therefore, it can be said that generally point blocks with smaller footprints than slab blocks provide greater flexibility in external layout design, requiring less earthworks and lower foundation costs.

CONCLUSION


Most low-cost flats in Malaysia can be described as slab block low-rise apartments. The ubiquity of this generic design, despite its functional and social inadequacies can be attributed to the misconception that, given the cost constraints there are no alternatives. But Low-rise point blocks in my opinion through more aesthetically pleasing, functional and socially acceptable can be more cost effective when compared to the slab block.







COMMERCIALIZATION

Back in 1995, not long after I set up my firm, I decided to focus on designing low-cost housing. We did not have any clients yet, but I made a bet that the demand for such housing would always be present, and if the designs we came up with were good, then commissions would come. The bet came good: in the following years, the government embarked on a programme to get the public and private sector to build for the low-income.

The government entrusted a government owned corporation, TPPT Sdn Bhd, to work with the private sector and State governments to build low-cost housing. The mood of the times is reflected in the book produced by a think-thank which was closely allied to the government: "Low-Cost Housing - A Definitive Study". The problem of housing for the low income was going to be solved!

This provided an opportunity for Arkitek M Ghazali to introduce our ideas for "point blocks": ie 5 storey walk-up blocks with only 4 or 8 units to each floor accessible from a single staircase . We found that point blocks were economical: the ratio of saleable area to total area we were able to get was more than 95% , compared to about 85% achieved by the conventional slab blocks which could have up to 16 units per floor accessed from a central corridor.



These point blocks were arranged in a hexagonal formation (the first hint of honeycomb housing). In terms of land-use efficiency, we found this to be as efficient as the conventional rectilinear layout. In addition, the point block concept created "defensible spaces" and I instinctively felt that the clustering of the flats offered a much more community-friendly environment.

The recession of 1997/98 put a stop to the would be boom in low-cost housing.

However, the firm was able to see quite a few of its ideas come to fruition:


Octagonal low-cost 5 storey point-block flats, eight units on each floor, laid out in a hexagonal grid in Nusajaya, Johor below:

Medium-cost students 5 storey point-block apartments, four units to each floor, laid out in a hexagonal grid in Universiti Industri Selangor, Batang Berjuntai, Selangor.

This 5-storey walk-up building concept could easily be married to the Honeycomb apartment idea...
 

Tuesday, November 8, 2016

High-rise housing

When I was a student in the 1970’s, experts were lining up to criticise social high-rise housing. This was the time when the infamous Pruitt Igoe high-rise apartments in the United States were being demolished.



Study after study showed that living in high-rise housing is less suited for habitation compared to more traditional kinds of dwellings.
A review of 129 high-rise research papers over 56 years on the human experience of tall buildings found little empirical support for high-rise housing. 
Aren't there any existing solutions on offer?

Green, social spaces on High-Rise Housing

One position to take is of course to insist high-rise housing should not be built at all. Another, is that somehow, high-rise housing is suitable for the rich but not the poor. Still, there have been attempts to overcome the drawbacks of high rise housing. We can look at the idea of providing gardens in the sky as a means of overcoming the social drawbacks of high-rise.

An early, celebrated one is Habitat '67, in Montreal by Moshe Safdie, a multi-storey housing project designed in a cascading pattern such that each apartment has its own private garden. However, providing each apartment with its own garden proved costly, and after Habitat 67, there have hardly been any apartment project that do so (Safdie, World Architecture Festival, 2015).

Habitat ‘67, Montreal
But that was until Singapore entered the picture in a big way with the Pinnacle@Duxton by a local firm, ARC Studio, which was completed in 2009. Singapore had always emphasized tree planting and making their crowded island green; they were now extending their parks upwards. The phrase “sky-rise greenery” was coined.

The Pinnacle@Duxton , ARC Studio
More recently, a spate of new projects that provide green communal spaces in the upper levels of high-rise housing.  Today new projects such as the Interlace (OMA Architects), Sky Habitat (Safdie), SkyVille@Dawson (SCDA Architects) and SkyTerrace@Dawson (WOHA) grace the pages of architectural magazines around the world.

The Interlace (OMA Architects)

Sky Habitat, Singapore (Safdie Associates)

SkyVille@Dawson in the foreground (WOHA) and
SkyTerrace@Dawson (SCDA Architects)
To my mind this trend really important in making much needed social improvements in high-rise housing. Indeed, these green social spaces in the air in these green social spaces in the air in should become more common-place.

But whilst providing sky-rise greenery is great, “sky-terraces” or “sky-courts” are extra expenses that have to be paid for. These sky-courts also take up space that could be used to fit in more apartments and so represent an opportunity cost. The issues of cost make sky-rise greenery both less affordable and less likely to be adopted by developers.

However, I believe that we can actually design them a way that makes it affordable for more people. What I will be introducing to you today is a layout concept where, additional areas for private and shared gardens in the sky courts can be balanced by a big reduction in the need for circulation space - achieved by largely eliminating the need for corridors.

And my aim is to try to convince you of that. But first, What exactly is wrong with high-rise housing?

It has been suggested that the defects of high rise housing spring mainly from the quality of these spaces between the street and the apartment, what author and architect Dalziel calls “intermediate spaces”, and which he laments as “weird anonymous space... neither public nor private”. 


Corridor
Lift lobby
These spaces are neither suited for children to play in or for adults to socialize.
A recent CTBUH article suggests that articulating the threshold between public and private domains by introducing the missing element of the semi-private realm has long been a challenge; failure to do so is a major drawback of the high rise residential typology.


From “Jan Gehl”, Cities for People, pp83
A blind corridor from Corbusier's Unite D'Habitation

Architect cum researcher Oscar Newman said about the same thing 40 years ago. Newman had observed that across the street from apartments that were eventually demolished was an older, low-rise complex occupied by people from the same background which remained fully occupied and trouble-free throughout the decline of the high-rise.

Newman’s theory was that it was the quality of the spaces just outside the low-rise homes compared with those outside the high-rise that made the difference.   He recommended that architects design in semi-private / semi- public spaces in between the dwellings and the street.


A low-rise solution: for everyone a private and a shared garden

His influence over my work of the last 10 years is very obvious. I try to create – through the arrangement of a private and a shared garden for each house - what Oscar Newman called “Defensible Space”; trying to humanize “intermediate space” and “articulating the threshold between public and private domains.”




In what I called “Honeycomb housing”, small groups of houses are laid out around a communal courtyard like friends sitting around a table.

The features of Honeycomb housing compared to conventional terrace houses make it easier for parents to allow their children to play outside their homes, encourage neighbours to know and interact with each other and perhaps even promote helping behaviour.
Compared to the conventional terrace house grid layout, the Honeycomb cul-de-sacs reduced the amount of land taken up by roads and increased the area available for private and shared gardens.

The previous chapters have outlined all this; I now want to do something similar for high-rise apartments.


Back to Table of Contents





GET A FREE HARDCOPY OF THIS BOOK IN FEBRUARY!!
Please help me proof-read this book. Just point out the errors in the comments section (look at the bottom left hand side of each post). 
I'll post this book to the first reader who spots 5 mistakes...!


Saturday, November 5, 2016

The Terrace Honeycomb Layout; a High-end Proposal in Petaling Jaya

For many years, my friends and I had been promoting cluster houses as a better alternative to terrace houses. In the projects that were procured, we had to show that, the cluster houses were able to yield a higher percentage of saleable land and as many units per acre compared to terrace houses. Yet, the comparisons involved producing two alternatives of equal value. Because cluster houses always had more land and a smaller footprint, the cluster houses would end up having more land but smaller built-up area compared to terrace houses. 

We could see that although land-use efficiency and density of the Honeycomb layout were respectively higher and the same as terrace houses but that the plot ratio – the amount of built-up area compared with the development land area - would always be lower. This wasn’t a problem to us. To compensate we would design efficient corridor free layouts, or add attic floors. 

But where land cost is high, the lower yield on built-up area obtained by cluster houses is a major disadvantage. Lower plot ratio means that the cost of land per square foot of sellable built-up area would be higher. In many urban situations where generous amounts of front and side gardens are unsuitable, the terrace house layout can maximize the saleable built-up area. 

CAN TERRACE HOUSES BE ARRANGED TO PRODUCE A HONEYCOMB LAYOUT WHERE THE HOUSES HAVE PRIVATE AND SHARED GARDENS? 

It took a long time to come around to ask this question - we had always had a Honeycomb vs terrace house mentality - but once posed, the answer came almost immediately. 
This is the conceptual drawing of the solution.




As can be seen, the advantages of Honeycomb housing have been achieved:
  • A small number of homes are arranged around cul-de-sac roads like friends sitting around a table
  • All the houses face a communal courtyard in front 
  • Traffic speed and volume in the cul-de sacs is minimized 
The key was producing a spine of terrace houses where the houses faced one direction then the other. You can see this spine running horizontally across the middle of the layout shown above. In this way cul-de-sac courtyards are consecutively created on both sides. 

MAKING BACKLANES WORK HARDER

Back lanes for terrace houses are mandatory in Malaysia. So, they had to be provided in the Honeycomb terrace house layout. Due to this, the land-use efficiency – expressed as sellable land as a percentage of total development land - would not be as high as the cluster layout, though better than conventional rows of terrace houses. On the other hand, the density achieved will be higher than cluster houses. But because Honeycomb terrace cul-de-sacs would comprise short rows of terrace houses, the total footprint area would be marginally lower than a conventional layout made up of long streets with multiple rows of terrace houses.

Still, the Honeycomb terrace house back lanes can be put to better use. Planning authorities have, over the years, been increasing the minimum width of back lanes, from 5’ to 10’ to 15’, and now it is 20’. At that width, cars can now traverse the back lanes and we can use them for access to car parks for residents placed at the rear of the houses. 





This has the advantage of allowing the front yard to become a garden and freeing the front streets from all cars except for service vehicles and visitors’ cars. With the much reduced car traffic and the unfenced front gardens, the cul-de-sac street is better able to serve as an arena for social interaction and children’s outdoor play.



A SPECULATIVE PROPOSAL IN PETALING JAYA

There is a small enclave of government quarters in an old part of Petaling Jaya which is ripe for redevelopment. However, it is located in a well-established neighbourhood next to a forest reserve which has staunchly defended against development as a vital green for the Klang valley. Despite its strategic location, anything other than low-rise, low density residential use would be out of the question. 



A well connected entrepreneur requested my firm to produce a preliminary design to put forward to the government; the case for the redevelopment of the dilapidated quarters is rather similar the case made for the Nong Chik development in Johor Bahru.

He asked that we design high-end terrace and semi-detached houses priced about RM1,500,000 or more. With only up to 12 units per acre, it was less likely to disturb the local residents and attract objections from them.

Semi-detached houses are laid out along the periphery of this rectangular site. An existing road is widened and adopted as the main entrance with a guardhouse. A club house and neighbourhood green area is placed just off this main entrance. The terrace houses are lined up in the direction of the slope, such that the back lanes can be set at a lower level than the front roads. 

This allows the garage at the rear to be a split level lower than the living room, with the dining, wet and dry-kitchens and bedroom 6 all siting above the garage, half a floor above the living room. The first floor is all on the same level, affording the living room a tall ceiling. On the first floor are four bedrooms with bathrooms ensuite, a family room and a balcony garden. On the second floor is a large master suite which has a roof-top garden.







Having the garage for three cars on the lower ground floor allows the whole of the front yard to become a garden, and freeing the front streets from all cars except for service vehicles and visitors’ cars. With the much reduced car traffic and the unfenced front gardens, the cul-de-sac street is capable of serving as an arena for social interaction and children’s outdoor play, even without a shared garden. 





The front-yard garden, first floor balcony garden and rooftop garden of each house is connected by a spiral staircase that allows access to a gardener without entering the house. It also allows the mistress of the house to walk down from the roof garden all the way down to the front sitting porch.





All the floors from the lower ground garage to the master suite can be accessed via a lift.  
The layout of the semi-detached house follows that of the terrace house, except that one side of the house has openings looking out to a side garden.

Although, this Petaling Jaya project did not take off, another opportunity did present itself. It was also an opportunity to propose a more diverse mix of house-types for a small project in Jasin, Melaka.

Back to Table of Contents

GET A FREE HARDCOPY OF THIS BOOK IN FEBRUARY!!
Please help me proof-read this book. Just point out the errors in the comments section (look at the bottom left hand side of each post). 
I'll post this book to the first reader who spots 5 mistakes...!